The BEST authentic Italian tomato sauce. Here's how!
Authentic Italian Tomato Sauce
Authentic Tomato Sauce...Italian-style
The secret to making an authentic Italian tomato sugo (sauce) for pasta is not as hard as you think. The answer is simple, do as the cunning Italiani do. Cheat...Italian-style! It is a well known fact that tomatoes are a summer crop in Italy & granted there is nothing more delicious than a ripe tomato picked fresh from the vine however these delicious morsels are not usually wasted in a cooked dish...moreover they are generally savoured fresh, on-their-own, solo. After the month of August when tomatoes are at their peak ripening stage there is normally a glut of produce; hence the "passata frenzy". This has become an event on the national calendar. During one week, usually around the beginning of September, entire families join forces to prepare the passata for bottling which will be then stored & used during the winter months when of course, tomatoes are non existent. Hard work but fun with a rewarding outcome!
To make a quick & very tasty sauce for pasta, Italians will generally use the canned variety...albeit of the absolute best quality. Living in Italy has exposed me to some of the best cooking teachers; the local women of my neighbourhood. In anticipation to taste the finished product, I have become a quick learner. This is one recipe that has now become a staple in my humble Umbrian kitchen, it is simple, quick & never fails me; now I am sharing it with you. Enjoy!
Authentic Italian Tomato Sugo (from Michelle's Umbrian Kitchen)
2 finely chopped onions
4 garlic cloves minced
a good slug of extra-virgin olive oil
a handful of fresh finely chopped Italian parsley, a bay leaf, some torn basil leaves
6 cans of quality chopped tomatoes + juice
*optional-a cup of pan roasted cherry tomatoes, salt & pepper to season.
Saute onion, garlic, sage & parsley in olive oil using a large deep pan, continue until onions are transparent taking care not to burn the garlic (it will be bitter). This should take about 5 minutes.
Add the tinned tomatoes & bay leaf stirring well to mix with onion. Place a lid partially covering the pan & simmer on medium heat until most of the liquid has evaporated & the sauce has thickened. If the mixture becomes too dry, add a little vegetable stock. Just before serving, add a few torn basil leaves (if you have them). Remove bay leaf before plating-up. How easy is that I ask you?
*This sauce makes approximately 6 cups, serving 6 people. It can be made while the pasta is boiling & will will in the fridge (well sealed) for up to 3 days. It marries well with either flat pasta ribbons, noodles or cut pasta shapes. Dont forget the bread to mop up the plate & a rustic "red" such as Montefalco Rosso to go with it!
Buon Apetito!
Comments
Hello Barb - 250 & 350g are the can sizes here. I buy these in flats of about 12 cans to store in my pantry over the winter months & use either size to make this.
I usually calculate x1 can tomatoes per person. This is one of my staples & a pretty simple "fool-proof" recipe to boot!
Pasta recipes
![]() | Amazon Price: $0.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $15.00 List Price: $30.00 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $10.00 List Price: $35.00 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $16.49 List Price: $35.00 |
Living in Italy Blog
- La Casa Umbra
Two Australians move to Italy, restore a country house & navigate life in a new land & a new language.




Barb 7 months ago
what size of canned tomatoes do you use?